It was World Left Handers Day on Wednesday. The day always causes me to reflect...
Amazingly, I learnt to write using my left hand. An achievement against the prevailing beliefs of the day. My very first teacher saw it as her mission in life to ‘fix’ the poor, wretched little boy suffering from what she clearly diagnosed as left handed disease. She must have thought, 'This child must be re-formatted! If he remains left handed he will be forever condemned to writing in a scrawl that no one will be able to read.' She actually told me this horrifying fact regarding my predicted fate.
They took the pencil out of my left hand and placed it in my right hand. It felt unnatural. It felt weird. It was not right. More importantly, it was not left. Watch me I said. I may be a left handed oddball, but I am a determined oddball. I mean how boring would the world be if everyone wrote with their right hand?
So I dug my toes in –and my hands too, and steadfastly resisted efforts to change my natural desire to be a left handed operator! Left handed liberty was my goal, and eventually I got the right to choose, –if you’ll pardon the pun. It was good enough for Alexander the Great to be left handed, not to mention Queen Victoria, Joan of Arc and Leonardo da Vinci as well as writers such as Lewis Carroll, Mark Twain, and H.G. Wells. I am in great company here people!
Famed Australian Indigenous author, Oodgeroo Noonnucal (aka Kath Walker) wrote about her experiences as a left-handed student in her memoir piece, 'The Left-Hander' in 'Hands Up' stories compiled by Barbara Ker Wilson.
'I soon realized that the Education Department in those days considered it wrong for a child to write or sew with the left hand. There were many painful scenes when I refused to pick up a pencil with my right hand; many times the Head Teacher's ruler came down in full force on the knuckles of my left hand.'
I have heard stories of fellow left-handed writers having their left hand forcibly restrained to restrict them from doing what was natural. Thankfully, educators now have a more enlightened view of we left-handed writers.
Not surpisingly, I persisted with my left-handed writing. I was not the fastest note-taker on the planet, but my writing was always legible, reader friendly. I was hell-bent on not being viewed as a scrawling scribbler. Sometimes the words of adults have long-lasting consequence - both good and bad. The initial diagnosis and the dire predictions of my teacher had a profound effect on my determination to prove her wrong.
I feel a sense of validation, when someone comments on the neatness of my writing . Writing neatly, if I'm honest, became something of an obsession. I never forgave them for trying to control my natural desire to remain a ‘leftie.’
I have delved into my poetry archive and using my left hand, retrieved a poem that featured in my first poetry anthology, 'Searching For Hen's Teeth. It refused to be left out...
When I started school
A prep still unbranded
They looked at me strangely
And observed
He's left handed !
Well I was just five
And my left hand felt right
I didn't consider its use was a blight
You'll have to change hands
Learn to write like the rest
The news didn't please me
I found it a pest
They handed me crayons
Scissors and chalk
All in my right hand
But this didn't work
I scribbled and chopped
I felt quite bereft
I desperately needed the use of my left
I didn't conform
I continued to fight
The use of my left
Was a personal right
So they left me to write
With the hand of my choosing
And to this very day
It's the left I'm still using.
Alan j Wright
From: 'Searching For Hen's Teeth -Poetry From The Search Zone, Alan j Wright'
So wrong that you had to fight the righters for the right to remain left! :)
ReplyDeleteA great story, great poem, and great penmanship, Alan!
It worked out all left in the end, Karen. Ironic that my surname is Wright, Kids often point this out to me. Thank you for your positive remarks. Always appreciated.
DeleteAlan, I am glad that you stood for your rights. These lines resonanted with me: The use of my left/Was a personal right." My 8-year-old granddaughter is a leftie and I have never heard from her that the teachers would say something that would upset her. I felt the sting of a 1st grade teacher who embarrassed me in front of the class. I never forgot that. Thanks for blog post and I too love your handwriting.
ReplyDeleteMy parents often commented on my stubborn streak, Carol. I preferred the term 'stickability.' It pleases me to hear about your grand-daughter's experience as a leftie. Your own experience with teacher remarks is testimony to the fact that we as educators create the climate in the classroom and our words require care. Thank you for your remarks.
DeleteAlan, wow, that is so wrong, isn't it? I'm glad you fought. I love all the clever uses of "right", "left", wrong, etc. in your post and poem.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad I fought too, Denise. It was an example of what my dear uncle used to refer to as 'quiet insurrection.' Thank you for noticing the deliberate wordplay in my poem.
DeleteWe really do never know which messages (well-intentioned or not) will survive childhood and become something absolutely formative to that adult's core being! Good for you that you persisted!
ReplyDeleteI absolutely agree with your comment, Mary Lee. We must remain aware of our messages to impressionable young minds.
DeleteAll the lefties I've known and taught were (and I think the research bears this out) the most creative and interesting people. I have longed to be left-handed myself. Your poem manages to be a personal story, a protest, and cleverly humorous all at the same time!
ReplyDeleteThank you for your affirming messages, Heidi. Being a creative contributor is an inner driving force. I shall continue striving to live up to the leftie legend.
DeleteAs a fellow lefty, I adore this poem. It's not easy living in a right-handed world, but I haven't met a lefty yet who hasn't risen to the challenge. (I still struggle with scissors, though!)
ReplyDeleteToo true, Tricia. I recall trying to play hockey at school- a game that didn't accommodate left-handedness. I was forced to play right-handed. We lefties are determined individuals- we have to be. Like you I found scissors, particularly the so called, left handed scissors, a pain. My family laugh at me setting the table for some reason.
DeleteThis is Janice. Poor you that you were shamed for being a leftie! But you persevered and became a poet using your left hand. It was fun reading your story and your poem.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Janice. It has all turned out okay in the end. That's what persistence can deliver.
DeleteLove this! Your penmanship is beautiful! So glad you stuck with your determination and proved that teacher wrong. You were right to keep left.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Rose. Your kindly remarks are much appreciated by this Lefty.
DeleteI don't know if all lefties are as gifted, but those I know have both beautiful handwriting and are also uniquely creative -- You fall into this wonderful group now, too!
ReplyDeleteWe lefties may be in the minority but we try to compensate with our determination to make a contribution. Thank you for your kind comments, Patricia.
Delete